Discovering the Best Vegan Cheese Pizza: A Delicious Journey

Apr 20

3 min read

Updated: Oct 7

Whether you're dairy-free by choice or necessity, finding a solid vegan cheese pizza can feel like winning the food lottery. For me, it’s not just about the toppings—it's all about the cheese. I’m allergic to dairy, but I’ll still indulge in real pepperoni sometimes, as long as the cheese is vegan. That makes me happy! This list focuses purely on the vegan cheese experience, not the full vegan topping lineup.

Here are my favorite spots for dairy-free cheese pizza across the country. I’ve included links so you can find them yourself and maybe even plan your own little pizza tour.

1. Saluggi's East – New York City, NY

This one’s at the top for a reason. Their vegan cheese melts perfectly, tastes great, and pairs wonderfully with that chewy NYC-style crust. It comes with fresh basil and never fails to impress me. If you love pepperoni, they have some of the freshest I’ve ever had on a pizza. It’s not a fully vegan spot, but if you’re dairy-free, it hits the mark every time.

2. Stone's Throw Pizza – Waterbury, VT

Unexpectedly good! Their vegan cheese is creamy and satisfying, while the dough strikes just the right balance of crispy and chewy. Hands down, it’s the best pizza place in Vermont, with multiple locations around the state. The cozy, laid-back vibe of this location is second to none.

3. Pi Pizzeria – Salt Lake City, UT

This one grew on me fast! The vegan cheese at Pi melts better than most and pairs well with their thicker crust style. The owners actually did research for their vegan cheese, and it truly shows in the quality. They are my favorite in Salt Lake City. It’s a chill spot, no matter which location you visit, with solid pies every time. Plus, try asking for their vegan ranch or their vegan pull-aparts—they're mouth-wateringly amazing!

4. Whole Foods (Mostly Nationwide)

Honestly, I’m not even embarrassed to include this. For the price and convenience, Whole Foods' vegan cheese pizza holds its own. In my experience, they don’t charge extra for making the pizza with vegan cheese. It costs around $15 for a large pizza, which is almost unheard of when you’re getting anything vegan. It’s consistent, tasty, and makes a great last-minute dinner when you’re on the road. Just be sure to call ahead to check if they have vegan cheese, as some stores don’t carry it all the time.

5. Gina’s Pizza – Laguna Beach, CA

Beach town pizza with a vegan option that doesn’t disappoint! The crust is thin and crisp, and the cheese holds up well. Plus, you’re in Laguna—can’t complain!

Honorable Mention:

Slackwater – Salt Lake City, UT

The vegan cheese here is decent—just not quite as melty or flavorful as Pi. Still, it deserves a mention, especially for the chill atmosphere and awesome beer list.

The Evolution of Vegan Cheese Pizza

Vegan cheese pizzas have come a long way. Whether you're hunting down your next slice in NYC or grabbing something quick on a road trip, there’s a good chance you’ll find something solid. The variety and quality of vegan cheese have improved tremendously, making it easier for those of us who are dairy-free to enjoy a delicious pizza experience.

Tips for Finding the Best Vegan Cheese Pizza

If you're dairy-free and constantly traveling like I am, here are a couple of quick tips:

Always double-check the cheese before ordering and when you pick it up (especially if you have allergies like me).
Don’t hesitate to call ahead and ask what brand of cheese they use. It can save you a lot of trouble!
If you find a Whole Foods in a pinch, that vegan pie can save your night.